
Floods are the subject of the last of three articles in the series “Three hazards, three Italies”, devoted to municipalities where a significant share of residents is exposed to a high natural hazard. The previous articles described two different Italies: that of earthquakes, the most widespread hazard, which affects 3,133 municipalities and weighs mainly on people, and that of landslides, which affects 1,280 municipalities, mostly small ones, and becomes rarer as population grows.
Floods draw a third geography. According to data from ISPRA (the Italian Institute for Environmental Protection and Research), the share of exposed municipalities increases with population size, and the hazard reaches the largest cities. Project databases, on the other hand, show that almost all exposed municipalities have at least one recorded project, with few exceptions. By number of municipalities, floods are the least widespread of the three hazards.
A municipality has a high flood hazard when at least 10% of its residents live in a P3 area, that is, an area of high flood hazard under the ISPRA classification. With this threshold, there are 719 municipalities out of 7,899, home to 6.7 million people. Not all of them, however, live in a P3 area: the threshold identifies the municipality, not the individual people exposed. As with landslides, the criterion looks at people rather than land, and it measures hazard, that is, the probability that the event occurs, not risk, that is, the expected damage.
Exposure rises from 6.4% among municipalities with fewer than 1,000 inhabitants to 12.4% among those with more than 20,000. This is a description, not a causal link. Of the people living in P3 areas, 87% reside in municipalities with more than 5,000 inhabitants, and just over half in those with more than 20,000.
Six in ten exposed municipalities have fewer than 5,000 inhabitants, but they are home to only 12.1% of the residents of exposed municipalities. They also include nine cities with more than 100,000 inhabitants, among them Venice and Rimini. In Venice about one resident in four lives in a P3 area; in Rimini, more than half.
The 10% threshold does not capture everyone: 1.5 million P3-area residents live in the exposed municipalities, the rest in municipalities where the P3 area weighs less. Six regions account for 71% of P3-area residents: almost half are in Emilia-Romagna, Veneto and Tuscany alone, followed by Calabria, Lombardy and Liguria. Relative to population, the share is highest in Calabria, Liguria and Emilia-Romagna. Calabria is also the region with the most exposed municipalities.
Flood hazard is almost independent of the other two: the correlation with landslides is close to zero, and no significant link emerges with earthquakes. Overlaps are nonetheless frequent, partly because seismic hazard is very widespread: more than half of exposed municipalities face at least one other high hazard.
Municipalities exposed to floods only have on average about 11,100 inhabitants, compared with 2,400 for those exposed to landslides only.
Of the exposed municipalities, 93.9% have at least one flood-defence project, while 44 have none. The count combines two sources: cohesion-policy projects (OpenCoesione) and works recorded in the public works monitoring system (MOP, Monitoraggio Opere Pubbliche). Flood-defence projects are those that the CUP classification (Codice Unico di Progetto, the unique project code) assigns to soil protection on watercourses, water regulation or other soil-protection infrastructure.
The result depends on this scope: restricting it to watercourses and water regulation, municipalities without a project rise to 91 (12.7%). Moreover, a municipality without projects is not necessarily one where no action is taken: it simply does not appear among the beneficiaries recorded in these two sources. Likewise, the presence of projects is not an assessment of their adequacy.
The share of exposed municipalities without a project falls as municipal size grows: from 14.1% below 1,000 inhabitants to none above 20,000 (Chart 1).
Less than 1% of P3-area residents live in municipalities without a project.
Municipalities without a project are concentrated in a few regions: Calabria, Lombardy, Liguria and Sardinia account for almost three in four, partly because of the number of exposed municipalities in each. Relative to exposed municipalities, the highest share is in the Aosta Valley, with 3 municipalities out of 13 (Chart 2). With such small numbers, percentages should be read with caution.
Overall, 51.4% of municipalities face at least one high hazard, and 53.7% of Italians live in them. The three hazards draw three different Italies: earthquakes weigh mainly through the number of people involved, landslides on small municipalities, floods on larger ones. For prevention planning, the type of hazard matters as well as how widespread it is.
For floods, coverage does not mean adequacy: the presence of a project does not tell whether the intervention is proportionate to exposure. This is the open question for the 2.4 million people living in P3 areas. This article does not measure that proportion. Two readings can help those in charge of planning:
Bringing data of this kind into the DUP (Documento Unico di Programmazione, the municipal single planning document) can help explain why one intervention is scheduled before another, separating what is declared a priority from what the data can document.